An overview of the canadian justice system versus the aboriginal people

There is little restoration of harmony within the community. This compares to about 1 in 6 or 7 of non-Aboriginal children. In this context we believe that the foundation for change is self-determination. But even more to the point, Europeans and Aboriginal people viewed the same crime of murder in different ways.

There were elders who counselled and advised individuals and the tribe on how to resolve disputes and relieve tensions.

Examples of such indigenous governments and their laws exist around the world. The International Forum There are many ways in which Canadian aboriginal leaders are connected to the international arena, three of which are of particular interest in the present context: TOP Our Recommendation TOP It is wrong, in our view, simply to maintain the status quo on the assumption that eventually Aboriginal people will learn to accept the justice system as it presently exists.

All things considered, Chief Justice MacEachern's judgement seems a regrettably classic example of the court serving as "the handmaiden of government" e. The New York Press; I was appalled to learn that a man had been hired [as an interpreter] who does not speak any native Aboriginal language at all and it still exists.

The Huron did not fine or penalize a thief, nor did they permit a man from whom goods had been stolen to reclaim them without first inquiring how someone else had come to possess them. Ross notes that this is the case among the Mohawks, where a reputation for lying follows one forever, and where, for one's third 'conviction' for lying -- which included such actions as attempting to deny or minimize one's behaviour -- the consequence was banishment.

Instead, the court, within four days of the incident, rushed to swear in Augustin Nolin as an interpreter for the Aboriginal who could not speak or understand English.

But these were extreme situations. Settlements of disputes are reached and witnessed in the feast hall with payments and demonstrations of power. Annual Report of the Office of the Correctional Investigator — Aboriginal ethics and rules of behaviour are "present in some form in all tribes of North America," according to Dr.

Similarly, Aboriginal people are many peoples, cultures and languages in many regions. According to Knafla, Thom consistently exceeded his authority in a drive to marginalize Aboriginal culture and institutions. A retrospective cohort study of adults imprisoned in NSW between and found that Indigenous men were 4.

Nonetheless, in the vast majority of incidences, there is eventually forgiveness and reconciliation. For instance, in general, Aboriginal people are non-confrontational. In many ways it is a self-fulfilling prophecy.

This disruption has interfered with the ability of Aboriginal people to deal with the various pressures confronting them. In keeping with the general tenor of that history, MacEachern believed that the aboriginals were a fallen people with little to offer.

By way of general summary, it can be seen that the Courts, and especially the Supreme Court, have, for the most part, rendered decisions which have been encouraging to aboriginal peoples. Through mathematical extrapolation it is possible to label all minorities as potential criminals.

Plea-making is another area where the mechanics of the Canadian justice system are in conflict with Aboriginal cultural values.

The importance of the ethic of non-interference helps to explain the use of stories in Aboriginal societies. Psychological and anthropological profiles of Ojibway, Dakota, Apache, Navajo and Cheyenne subjects have identified recurring personality characteristics which seem to be culturally induced and which are so universal that they could be equated with "primary Native values.

Internal, unofficial communication was the process. This villain might take the shape of a witch or a monster and originally was used to discipline people by implied threat. But the Canadian position has been an extremely cautious one, much to the chagrin of aboriginal representatives.

Native people however, regard it neither as a political ideology nor as a religious requirement. Government of Canada; This more recent account of Aboriginal society in Canada describes almost the same situation as does the previous author, but from a more neutral viewpoint: In Aboriginal beliefs, if only the body is treated, then healing cannot take place properly.

For example, there are subtle differences in social characteristics between the Swampy Cree of northwestern Manitoba and the plains Cree in Saskatchewan. The Hudson’s Bay Company ignored the autonomy of the Aboriginal people and dragged them into the Company’s criminal justice system, while at the same time, excluding the Aboriginal people from the benefits of the civil side of the same legal system.

Get an answer for 'Discuss the treatment of aboriginal people by the Canadian justice system. what would be a good thesis for this? ' and find homework help for other Law and Politics questions at.

How the Canadian Legal System Fails Indigenous People

The Justice System and Aboriginal People. For Aboriginal people, the essential problem is that the Canadian system of justice is an imposed and foreign system.

The Manitoban

In order for a society to accept a justice system as part of its life and its community, it must see the system and experience it as being a positive influence working for that.

How the Canadian Legal System Fails Indigenous People. To assume they can do their job without a basic understanding of the history of Canadian colonialism and Aboriginal law is more than a failure to appreciate the relationship between knowledge, understanding and justice.

history and the law the Canadian legal system will. The Aboriginal Administration of Justice Offences (AAJO) Research Project was initiated in response to the over- The Aboriginal Administration of Justice Offences Research Project was intended disproportionate number of Aboriginal people in the criminal justice system compared to.

Second, the analysis above suggests that aboriginal justice, at least in its traditional forms, is in many ways incompatable with the dominant Euro-Canadian model, to the extent that justice delivery within aboriginal communities must allow an appearance which differs radically from that in .

An overview of the canadian justice system versus the aboriginal people
Rated 0/5 based on 82 review
Aboriginal Justice in Canada (Palys, )